judgesonmerit.org

From our friends at Gavel Grab:

Former Wisconsin Justice Louis Butler Jr. . . . . nominated by President Obama to the federal bench in Wisconsin, was asked by a GOP senator at a confirmation hearing in Washington about his defeat in two elections for the state’s high court.”

We can only imagine the very slight smile that must have formed on the corner of Butler’s lips as he made this reply:

‘After 16 years on the bench, I may be a better judge than politician,’ replied Butler, according to an article in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.”

Butler was defeated last year in an ugly contest with then-Judge Michael Gableman, who now faces an ethics complaint accusing him of lying in a campaign ad aired against Butler.”

Some judges would no doubt make excellent and effective politicians, and some politicians would likely make fine judges. But we think using mere “electability” as the decisive factor in how we choose our judges leaves too much to chance, and gives too much weight to factors other than a candidate’s qualifications.  For choosing our judges, being a good politician should not be more important than being fair, impartial, and wise. Judges should be chosen on merit.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS