Oct 21 2008

What’s Going on in Nevada?

Published by at 12:16 pm under Judges,News

The Las Vegas Sun’s report on the Nevada Supreme Court elections discloses disturbing allegations about whether campaign contributions might have been offered in exchange for a promise to recuse from the donor’s cases.  The candidate has alleged that a political consultant close to another lawyer — and long-time “enemy” of the candidate — approached the candidate with the promise of large campaign donations in exchange for the agreement to recuse in the “enemy’s” cases.  The FBI was alerted, but as yet, no charges have been filed.

The news report bemoans the state of judicial elections in Nevada:

But even if no crime has been committed — and lawyers disagree on whether one was — the notion that such a conversation took place will confirm the worst cynicism about how campaigns and the judiciary work in our little backwater in the desert. That L.A. Times series [from 2006], headlined “A stacked judicial deck,” detailed how judges apparently were influenced by friendships and contributions — it was a manifesto for an appointive judicial selection process.

The public has grown increasingly concerned that campaign contributors get favored treatment in the courtroom.  This story raises a new question — could contributors use their money not to curry favor but to get unfavorable judges out of the courtroom?

Conspiracy theories and ugly tactics are de rigueur for October in even-numbered years. But what makes this different is the unmasking (again) of a system in which lawyers spend lots of money trying to get a favorable majority on the high court, where justices can help determine where millions of dollars in settlements will go or how much money deep pockets will save.

Whether or not the allegations in this story are proven to be true, the damage to the court system and the judiciary has been done.  This story reinforces the public perception that money matters in the courtroom, and it demonstrates once again why we need to get judges out of the fundraising business.

Tags: , , , , ,

2 responses so far

2 Responses to “What’s Going on in Nevada?”

  1. […] to our partners at Choose Judges on Merit for pointing out this Las Vegas Sun Article, which sheds further light on the Nevada Supreme […]

  2. Gavel Grab » links for 2008-10-23on 23 Oct 2008 at 7:00 am

    […] judgesonmerit.org » What’s Going on in Nevada? […]

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply